Marketers Misjudge ChatGPT Ads By Comparing To Google Search
Marketers are evaluating ChatGPT ads using search-era metrics, which may not accurately capture their value. This approach risks underestimating the performance of conversational AI ads.
Original reporting · adexchanger.com
Original: “Measuring Clicks Is Making ChatGPT Ads Look Like A Bad Bet”
Read “Measuring Clicks Is Making ChatGPT Ads Look Like A Bad Bet” at AdExchanger →
How this was written. Clicktag wrote this article with a language model from AdExchanger’s reporting (model: @cf/meta/llama-3.3-70b-instruct-fp8-fast); it describes that reporting rather than adding to it. The original, linked above, is the full story.
Key points from AdExchanger’s report
- Marketers are evaluating ChatGPT ads using search-era metrics, which may not accurately capture their value.
- Conversational AI has a different customer journey than search, shaping intent rather than capturing it.
- Traditional metrics, such as CPAs, may not accurately capture the value of conversational AI ads due to the complexity of the customer journey.
- Measurement frameworks used for traditional advertising may not be suited for conversational AI, requiring a shift in approach.
- Conversational AI has the potential to monetize the conversation that creates intent, rather than just harvesting existing intent.
Marketers are asking the wrong questions about ChatGPT advertising, according to AdExchanger. They are comparing its performance to Google Search, wondering if it can deliver lower CPAs and convert as well. However, this comparison may not be fair, as conversational AI and search have different customer journeys.
The customer journey for conversational AI is fundamentally different from search, as it shapes intent rather than capturing it. When a user interacts with conversational AI, they may provide more detailed information about their needs and preferences, allowing advertisers to participate in the development of intent.
Google's advertising business is built on harvesting intent, where users search for specific keywords and advertisers provide relevant results. In contrast, conversational AI helps users explore options and refine priorities before making a purchase. This difference in approach means that traditional metrics, such as CPAs, may not accurately capture the value of conversational AI ads.
Marketers may notice that acquisition metrics for conversational AI appear higher than those for search, leading them to conclude that the channel is not competitive. However, this conclusion may be flawed, as the customer journey for conversational AI is more complex and nuanced. Users who interact with conversational AI may be more informed and better qualified, leading to higher acquisition costs but also potentially higher value.
The measurement frameworks used for traditional advertising may not be suited for conversational AI, as they are based on clicks and attribution models. Conversational AI changes the game, as the interaction influencing a purchase may occur long before a click, and traditional attribution may not capture this value. Early evidence suggests that measuring incremental business outcomes may provide a more accurate picture of conversational AI's effectiveness.
The industry is focused on whether OpenAI can compete with Google, but a better question may be whether conversational AI should be evaluated like search at all. Every evolution in advertising has required marketers to rethink measurement, and conversational AI is no exception. It has the potential to monetize the conversation that creates intent, rather than just harvesting existing intent.
Unless marketers adapt their measurement approaches, they risk underestimating the performance of conversational AI ads and the role they may play in the future of digital advertising. By moving beyond traditional metrics and attribution models, marketers can gain a better understanding of the value that conversational AI can provide.
Questions and answers
Why are marketers misjudging ChatGPT ads?
Marketers are evaluating ChatGPT ads using search-era metrics, which may not accurately capture their value.
How does conversational AI differ from search?
Conversational AI shapes intent rather than capturing it, and helps users explore options and refine priorities before making a purchase.
What is the potential risk of using traditional metrics to evaluate conversational AI ads?
The potential risk is underestimating the performance of conversational AI ads and the role they may play in the future of digital advertising.



